Skip to content
Tool reviews

Jenni AI vs Consensus: Which Checks and Cites a Thesis Paragraph Better?

Justin Wong

Head of Growth

10 min read

Comparison: Jenni puts 2 edits, 4 comments and a full reference in the draft; Consensus rates 7 claims partially supported

Consensus shows you what published studies say. A strict supervisor will check the paragraph you write next for claims your sources support and complete references.

TLDR: Jenni or Consensus?

Jenni AI is an AI research and writing assistant: it finds sources and cites them inside your draft. Consensus is an AI academic search engine: it answers questions using published studies.

Choose Jenni if - you want weak sentences flagged and fixed inside your draft, plus complete references.

Choose Consensus if - you want to see what published studies say about a question before you write.


Jenni

Consensus

Checking the argument

Comments on the weak sentences, in the draft

Ratings in a list, your sentences left as written

Citing the claim

Complete APA reference, with volume, issue and pages

APA reference missing volume, issue and pages

Fixing a clunky sentence

Rewrite in your draft, every change marked

Rewrite in a chat answer, to copy back by hand

Getting the file out

Word file, citations still linked to the reference list

Copied text or a PDF, papers exportable to Zotero

Seeing how studies split

Jenni does not do this

Counts papers that say yes or no to a question

Price

Free plan; Plus $30 a month or $144 a year; Pro $73 a month or $348 a year

Free plan; Pro $20 a month or $144 a year; Deep $65 a month or $540 a year

More on Consensus - the Jenni review of Consensus is a full post on Consensus alone. The Elicit vs Consensus post compares it with Elicit, another research tool.

All 4 writing rows in the table come from one test thesis paragraph, with 3 problems we added on purpose. One sentence stacked 3 hedge words in a row. Hedge words make a claim sound less certain.

Consensus adds sources but does not change your words, so it put a citation on that sentence and left the hedge words in. Its rating, in a list under the paragraph, said to remove them. But to a reader, a sentence with a citation looks checked.

Jenni put a comment on the sentence itself, saying what to change. The paragraph also had a figure from a clinical trial with no source. Both tools found the trial, and Jenni's reference for it was the complete one.

The rest of this post covers:

  • How we tested - the paragraph and its 3 problems.

  • 4 writing jobs - how each tool did.

  • 1 research job - one that Consensus does and Jenni does not.

  • Strengths, prices and advice - where each tool is ahead, what each costs, and which to use.

Get comments on the sentences that need them

Peer Review in Jenni scores your draft like a reviewer and puts each comment on the passage it is about

Try Jenni Free

How the test worked

The test used one 201-word thesis paragraph about lipid nanoparticles carrying a gene-editing tool to the liver. We added 3 problems on purpose:

  • A clunky sentence - 43 words long, opening with 2 grammar mistakes.

  • 3 hedge words in a row - "could perhaps maybe", in the sentence about reaching organs other than the liver.

  • A claim with no source - an 87% drop in a blood protein, from a 2021 trial in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM). The draft never cites the trial.

The topic is biology, but problems like these turn up in drafts in any field.

The limits - this is one paragraph, not a whole thesis. 4 of the 5 jobs are about writing, which suits Jenni. The 5th is about research, which suits Consensus.

Here is the full paragraph, with the 3 problems in bold.

"Lipid nanoparticles have become the most clinically advanced non-viral vehicle for delivering CRISPR-Cas9 to the liver, and the reason is mostly pharmacological rather than genetic. The particle protects the messenger RNA and guide RNA in circulation, it is taken up by hepatocytes through apolipoprotein E mediated endocytosis, and the cargo is transient, so the nuclease is expressed for days rather than for the life of the cell. The first in-human systemic trial of an LNP delivered CRISPR therapy reported a mean reduction in serum transthyretin of 87 percent at the higher dose after a single infusion. There is a lot of things that still needs to be worked out though, for example how the particles behave outside the liver, whether repeat dosing causes an immune response, and what the long term editing outcomes look like at off target sites. It is possible that ionizable lipid chemistry could perhaps maybe be the main lever for extrahepatic targeting, although this has not been conclusively shown. Taken together, the evidence suggests that LNP delivery is a mature platform for hepatic gene editing and an immature one for everything else, which is the gap that most of the current preclinical work is trying to close."

Checking the argument: comments on the sentence or ratings in a list

Winner - Jenni, because its comment sits on the sentence with the 3 hedge words and says what to change. Neither tool rewrote that sentence for you, and Consensus kept its advice in a list under the paragraph.

What Jenni did

We ran 2 of Jenni's checks:

  • Claim confidence - checks each claim against its sources and suggests edits in the draft.

  • Peer Review - reads the draft like a reviewer, gives it a score and leaves comments.

Claim confidence found the 87% figure was right, but the sentence never said the result was interim, meaning an early result, not the final one.

The sentence already tied the 87% to the higher dose. The edit added that it was measured at day 28, in an interim analysis of 6 patients. It also attached the trial paper.

The edit also dropped a detail the trial abstract supports: the result came after a single infusion. So read each suggestion before accepting it.

Then Peer Review scored the edited paragraph 7/10 and put each of its 4 comments on the passage it is about.

Screenshot of the test paragraph in Jenni with 4 passages highlighted for Peer Review, including the stacked hedge words

The hedge words are 1 of 4 highlighted passages, each with its own comment

The comment on the hedge words asked for a narrower claim. It began "“Could perhaps maybe” stacks hedges without clarifying the degree of uncertainty." It also pointed to Zhuo et al. (2021), a paper on another way to reach organs other than the liver.

What Consensus did

Consensus gave back 2 things:

  • A cited paragraph - its citation search finds studies for or against each sentence. Every sentence got a citation, and the wording stayed the same.

  • Ratings under the paragraph - it rated 7 of the 8 claims Partially supported, each with a suggested change.

Consensus confirmed the 87% figure and, like Jenni, suggested adding the number of patients and when the drop was measured.

Screenshot of a Consensus rating, Partially supported, suggesting 'one important lever' in place of 'the main lever'

The fix for the hedge words stays in a list under the paragraph

For the hedge words, it suggested "Replace “the main lever” with “one important lever” and remove the repeated hedging." The cited paragraph does not include that change.

It still has the 3 hedge words, now backed by Song 2024, a source Consensus added. Copy that paragraph as it is, and the hedge words go into your thesis with a citation.

📌 Check each cited sentence against its rating: In Consensus, citations sit inside the paragraph and ratings sit under it. Read the rating before you copy the sentence

Citing the claim: a complete reference or one missing 3 details

Winner - Jenni, because its APA reference had the volume, issue and pages. The Consensus reference left out all 3.

What Jenni did

Jenni's citation search runs inside your draft. One catch: when we searched the claim's key terms, the trial came 5th, after a 2022 reprint with the same title. Check that the year says 2021 before you cite.

Citing it took one click. (Gillmore et al., 2021) went in after the sentence, and Jenni started the reference list in APA (7th ed.). Jenni lists 10,000+ citation styles, and this test checked APA only.

Screenshot of the Jenni APA 7th reference list: the Gillmore et al. 2021 NEJM entry with 385(6), 493–502 and DOI

The Jenni reference has the volume, issue and pages

The reference's volume, issue and pages, "385(6), 493–502", match the PubMed record. The DOI comes with them.

What Consensus did

Asked about the 87% sentence, Consensus confirmed it and listed the NEJM paper first. The problem was the reference it gave.

Its APA reference for the trial ends like this, exactly as Consensus printed it, double period included:

"(2021). CRISPR-Cas9 In Vivo Gene Editing for Transthyretin Amyloidosis.. The New England journal of medicine. https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmoa2107454"

Screenshot of the Consensus 'Cite this finding' APA tab: the Gillmore entry has the journal and DOI but no volume or pages

The Consensus reference has no volume, issue or pages

APA Style asks for the volume, issue and page range in a journal reference. This one has none of the 3, so you would add them by hand before your supervisor sees it.

📚 Match the reference to PubMed: Compare any reference a tool gives you with the PubMed record of the paper before it goes into your reference list

Cite with the volume, issue and pages included

One click on Cite adds the in-text citation and an APA reference with volume, issue, pages and DOI under your draft

Start Writing Free

Fixing a clunky sentence: marked edits or a rewrite to copy

Winner - Jenni, because its rewrite appears in your draft with every change marked and a note on what changed. Both tools fixed the grammar.

Both rewrites started with the same 3 words. Jenni's had 28 words and Consensus's had 31, down from 43.

Jenni - its fluency edit, for smoother wording, returned "Several questions remain, including how the particles behave outside the liver, whether repeat dosing triggers an immune response, and what the long-term editing outcomes are at off-target sites."

Consensus - its rewrite began "Several questions remain unresolved, however" and listed the same 3 questions. It sat in a chat answer, with its changes listed, so you copy it back into your draft by hand.

Getting the file out: a Word file or copied text

Winner - Jenni, for a Word file you can keep editing, with each citation still linked to the reference list.

Exporting from Jenni

If your thesis is in Word, Jenni's export keeps each citation in Word's own citation format, linked to the reference list. For Google Docs, choose hyperlinked citations instead. Jenni also exports LaTeX.

Screenshot of Jenni's Word export: 'MS Word native citations' selected, 'Hyperlink citations' offered for Google Docs

Citations stay linked in Word, or hyperlinked in Google Docs

Exporting from Consensus

From Consensus you can copy the cited paragraph as text, or save it as a PDF. There is no Word export.

📎 Keep the papers Consensus cited: Before you move on, save them as an RIS file, a reference file that Zotero, EndNote and Mendeley can import

Seeing how studies split: a job Jenni does not do

Winner - Consensus, because it shows how many papers say yes and how many say no to a question.

The test paragraph treats one point as an open question: does repeat dosing cause an immune response? We asked Consensus that question. It answered "Yes, repeat dosing triggers immune responses that can cause accelerated clearance and systemic inflammation."

Screenshot of the Consensus Meter, N = 13: a bar with 12 papers yes and 1 no, read as Yes 92%, Possibly 0%, Mixed 0%, No 8%

The Consensus Meter: 92% yes, from 13 papers

Its Consensus Meter sorted 13 papers: 12 said yes and 1 said no. That is the 92% in the screenshot. Consensus adds that the meter "may not be a perfect reflection of the current science".

The draft calls this point open. Read those 13 papers before you keep that wording.

📊 Check how many papers are behind the meter: A split from 13 papers is a reading list, not a verdict

Where Jenni is ahead

  • Every job in one draft - checking, citing, rewriting and exporting all happen in your document.

  • Complete references - the volume, issue and pages arrive with the citation.

  • Edits you can accept - accept a Claim confidence suggestion, and Jenni rewrites the sentence and attaches its source.

  • Citations that stay linked in Word - the export uses Word's own citation format, not pasted text.

What Consensus has that Jenni does not

  • A meter for yes or no questions - it counts how many papers say yes and how many say no. Jenni has no equivalent, and checks the claims in your own draft instead.

  • A graph of linked papers - Consensus can draw a citation graph from the first 5 papers of a search. It shows which papers cite which. Jenni instead finds papers one sentence at a time, from inside your draft.

What each tool costs

Plan

Jenni

Consensus

Free plan

Free - $0; 10 AI Autocompletes (sentence completions) a day; 3 AI Edits (rewrites); 5 AI Chat messages; 3 Reviews (draft checks); unlimited citations

Free - $0; basic paper search; 10 Pro messages a month; up to 3 Deep reviews a month

First paid plan

Plus - $30 a month, or $144 a year

Pro - $20 a month, or $144 a year

Top plan

Pro - $73 a month, or $348 a year

Deep - $65 a month, or $540 a year

Prices from jenni.ai/pricing and consensus.app/pricing.

  • Paying yearly - Jenni Plus and Consensus Pro both cost $144 a year.

  • Paying monthly - Consensus Pro is $10 a month cheaper than Jenni Plus.

  • What Jenni Plus covers - 500 AI Edits a month, the rewrites used for the clunky sentence. It also covers 10 Reviews a month. Peer Review is one of the Reviews.

  • What Jenni Pro adds - no caps on AI Edits or Reviews.

Which one should you use?

If your supervisor checks every reference

Use Jenni - the reference arrives with its volume, issue and pages. Weak wording, like the hedge words, gets flagged before your supervisor reads the draft.

Hand your supervisor a Word file with linked citations

Jenni exports your draft to Word with each citation still linked to the reference list

Start Writing Free

If you are exploring a question before you write

Use both - ask Consensus how the studies split, then export its papers as an RIS file for Zotero. Write and cite the chapter in Jenni. Jenni can import from Zotero and Mendeley.

If your paragraph already has citations

Use Jenni - run Claim confidence, Jenni's claim check, to fix the claims inside the paragraph. Then run Peer Review, its reviewer-style read, for comments on what still needs work.

Start your next chapter in Jenni, so each citation, its full reference and the comments on your argument are in one document.

Make progress on your greatest work, today

Write your first paper with Jenni today and never look back

Start for free

No credit card required

Cancel anytime

Start writing– it's free

Over 8m

Academics worldwide

5.2 hours saved

On average per paper

Over 15m

Papers written on Jenni