Content par jaayein
टूल समीक्षाएँ

Jenni AI vs Elicit AI: Research se thesis likhne mein kaunsi AI zyada madad karti hai?

Nathan Auyeung

Senior Accountant EY mein

14 मिनट में पढ़ें

Comparison: Jenni draft mein edits aur poora NEJM reference rakhta hai; Elicit chat mein 8 claims rate karta hai, text jaisa hai waisa chhodta hai

Elicit aapki thesis ke liye papers dhoondhta hai aur unme kya likha hai wo nikaalta hai, lekin chapter likhna abhi bhi aapka kaam hai. Aapka supervisor check karega ki har claim uske paper se match karta hai aur har reference poora hai ya nahi.

TLDR: Jenni ya Elicit?

Jenni AI ek AI research aur writing assistant hai: ye sources dhoondhta hai aur unhe aapke draft ke andar hi cite karta hai. Elicit scientific research ke liye AI hai: ye papers dhoondhta hai aur unke findings ko tables me laata hai.

Jenni chunein agar - aap chahte hain ki kisi overstated claim ko aapke draft ke andar hi correct kiya jaaye, aur uska source poori tarah se cite ho.

Elicit chunein agar - aap likhne se pehle kai saare papers se same details ko ek table me laana chahte hain.


Jenni

Elicit

Claims ko check karna

Aapke draft me edits, har ek apne source ko quote karta hai

Batata hai ki har claim supported hai ya nahi, draft unchanged rehta hai

Claim ko cite karna

Ek click me citation aur poora APA reference

Paper ka naam diya jaata hai, paste karne ke liye koi formatted reference nahi

Clunky sentence ko fix karna

Har badlaav marked hone aur ek chhote note ke saath rewrite

Sirf rewrite, changes ki koi list nahi

File export karna

Word ya LaTeX, ek ready-made thesis layout ke saath

Chat answers plain text ke roop me, reports PDF ya Word ke roop me

Kai papers se details nikaalna

Jenni ye nahi karta

Aapke bataye anusar ek column jodta hai, jo har paper ke liye fill hota hai

Price

Free plan; Plus $30 prati maheena, ya yearly pay karne par $144 prati saal; Pro $73 prati maheena, ya yearly pay karne par $348 prati saal

Free plan; Plus $19 prati maheena, ya yearly pay karne par $132 prati saal; Pro $69 prati maheena, ya yearly pay karne par $468 prati saal

Elicit par aur details - Jenni review of Elicit isko akele analyse karta hai, aur Elicit vs Consensus post isko ek doosre research tool ke saath compare karta hai.

Humne ek thesis paragraph par table ke checking, citing, rewriting aur exporting ke kaam test kiye, jise jaanboojhkar 3 problems ke saath likha gaya tha. Iski sabse badi problem thi ek trial result jisme koi source aur patient count nahi diya gaya tha. Isme ek clunky sentence aur lagatar 3 hedge words bhi the, jo claim ko unsure sound karwate hain.

Elicit ne us result ko ek chat me check kiya aur bataya ki kya add karna hai, lekin draft waisa hi raha. Jenni me, trial paper ke quote ke saath fix draft ke andar hi aa gaya, aur accept karte hi sentence badal gaya.

Ye post in cheezon ko cover karta hai:

  • Test - paragraph me 3 problems, aur ek paragraph kya dikha sakta hai aur kya nahi.

  • 4 writing jobs - claims check karna, trial ko cite karna, sentence fix karna aur chapter export karna.

  • 1 research job - kai papers se same details ko ek table me laana, jo Elicit karta hai aur Jenni nahi karta.

  • Strengths aur prices - kaun sa tool kis cheez me aage hai aur dono ki cost kya hai.

  • Kaun sa use karein - 3 situations aur har ek ke liye sahi tool.

Kisi overstated claim ko wahi theek karein jahan aapne use likha hai

Claim confidence, ek Jenni check, har claim ko uske source se compare karta hai aur paper ko quote karte hue aapke draft ke andar hi fix suggest karta hai

Jenni Free Try Karein

Humne dono tools ko kaise test kiya

Test paragraph 201 words lamba hai, jo tiny fat particles ke baare me hai jo gene-editing tool ko liver me le jaate hain. Humne, yaani Jenni team ne, jaanboojhkar 3 problems add kiye:

  • Bina source ka ek claim - draft ek blood protein me 87% drop report karta hai lekin kuch bhi cite nahi karta. Ye figure ek 2021 trial in the New England Journal of Medicine se aata hai, aur draft me kabhi ye nahi bataya gaya ki ye kitne patients se aaya hai.

  • Ek clunky sentence - 43 words, jo 2 grammar mistakes se shuru hota hai.

  • Lagatar 3 hedge words - "could perhaps maybe". Hedge words claim ko kam certain sound karwate hain.

Topic biology hai. Doosri fields ke drafts me bhi yehi 3 tarah ki problems hoti hain, isliye agar ye aapka area nahi hai toh trial details ko skim kar sakte hain.

Ye test kya dikha sakta hai aur kya nahi - ye ek paragraph ko cover karta hai, poori thesis ko nahi. 5 me se 4 writing jobs hain, wo side jiske liye Jenni bana hai. 5th research job hai, wo side jiske liye Elicit bana hai.

Yahan wo paragraph hai, jisme 3 problems bold me hain.

"Lipid nanoparticles have become the most clinically advanced non-viral vehicle for delivering CRISPR-Cas9 to the liver, and the reason is mostly pharmacological rather than genetic. The particle protects the messenger RNA and guide RNA in circulation, it is taken up by hepatocytes through apolipoprotein E mediated endocytosis, and the cargo is transient, so the nuclease is expressed for days rather than for the life of the cell. The first in-human systemic trial of an LNP delivered CRISPR therapy reported a mean reduction in serum transthyretin of 87 percent at the higher dose after a single infusion. There is a lot of things that still needs to be worked out though, for example how the particles behave outside the liver, whether repeat dosing causes an immune response, and what the long term editing outcomes look like at off target sites. It is possible that ionizable lipid chemistry could perhaps maybe be the main lever for extrahepatic targeting, although this has not been conclusively shown. Taken together, the evidence suggests that LNP delivery is a mature platform for hepatic gene editing and an immature one for everything else, which is the gap that most of the current preclinical work is trying to close."

Claims ko check karna: sentence ke andar fix ya chat me advice

Winner - Jenni, kyunki iska fix sentence ke andar hi integrate ho gaya, jisme source ke roop me trial paper ka quote shamil tha. Dono tools ne ye pakda ki 87% ek chote, shuruati result se aaya tha. Elicit ne sabhi 8 claims ko rate kiya aur apne fixes ek chat me chhod diye.

Jenni ne kya kiya

Claim confidence ek Jenni check hai jo har claim ko uske sources ke saath compare karta hai. Jenni ka har kaam ek hi document me lagatar hua, isliye is point tak clunky sentence fix ho chuka tha aur trial cite ho chuka tha. Elicit ko original paragraph mila, jisme trial sentence usi tarah worded tha.

Claim confidence ne draft ke andar 2 suggestions diye:

  • Trial figure - Overstated mark kiya gaya. Naya sentence ye tha: "In an interim analysis of six patients receiving systemic LNP-delivered CRISPR therapy, mean serum transthyretin fell by 87 percent at the higher dose at day 28." Interim ka matlab hai trial khatam hone se pehle data par ek shuruati look.

  • Particles liver cells me kaise jaate hain us par sentence - Unsupported mark kiya gaya. Jenni ne isko trial paper ke hisaab se reword kiya aur us paper ko cite kiya.

Humne dono ko accept kar liya, aur har edit ne apne source ke roop me trial paper ka ek quote dikhaya. Jenni ki summary ne ek aise claim ki taraf bhi ishara kiya jise usne change nahi kiya tha: paragraph ki opening line, jisme abhi bhi koi citation nahi hai.

Jenni edits ka screenshot, purane shabd laal mein kate aur naye hare mein, aur Gillmore et al. 2021 ka hawala deta 'Unsupported' card

Paragraph me Jenni ke dono edits, jisme particle-entry sentence ke liye suggestion khula hai

Trial edit me 2 catches the, isliye accept karne se pehle har suggestion ko zaroor padhein:

  • Ek detail chhut gaya - "after a single infusion", jise trial abstract support karta hai.

  • Ek loose count - naya sentence 87% ko 6 patients ke saath jodta hai, halanki unme se sirf 3 ko hi higher dose mila tha.

Claim confidence ne 3 hedge words ko touch nahi kiya, lekin Peer Review, jo Jenni ka draft ko reviewer ki tarah read karne wala check hai, ne un par comment kiya. Iska comment aise shuru hua: "“Could perhaps maybe” stacks hedges without clarifying the degree of uncertainty." aur aage ek narrow, supported point suggest kiya.

Elicit ne kya kiya

Humne Elicit ko original paragraph diya aur unsupported ya overstated claims ko flag karne ke liye kaha. Usne paragraph ke sabhi 8 claims ko rate kiya aur har ek ke liye reasons aur ek source diya, kul milakar 4 sources ka use karte hue.

Trial figure par usne kaha "supported, but specify the endpoint and timing", aur group ka naam bataya: higher dose par 3 participants, jinka day 28 par measurement hua tha.

3 hedge words wale sentence par usne kaha "plausible, not established as the main lever". Iski rating claim ke baare me thi: research is idea ko doosre organs tak pahunchne ke liye ek possible lever ke roop me back karti hai, main lever ke roop me nahi.

Elicit chat jawab ka screenshot jo claims ko rate karta hai, 87 percent figure supported hai par endpoint aur timing chahiye

Elicit apne chat answer me har claim ko rate karta hai, har ek ke liye ek source ke saath

Paragraph khud change nahi hua. Elicit se fix use karne ke liye, aapko wording apne draft me manually copy karni padti hai.

Claim ko cite karna: draft me reference ya list me ek paper

Winner - Jenni, kyunki ek click ne draft ke andar citation aur ek complete APA reference add kar diya. Elicit ne wahi trial bataya par paste karne ke liye koi formatted reference nahi diya.

Jenni ne kya kiya

Jenni ke citation search me, humne claim ke key terms type kiye. Usi title wala 2022 ka reprint 4th number par aaya aur 2021 ka trial 5th number par, isliye cite karne se pehle year zaroor check karein.

Trial par ek click ne sentence ke baad (Gillmore et al., 2021) add kar diya aur paragraph ke neeche ek APA reference list shuru kar di. APA un 10,000+ citation styles me se ek hai jo Jenni provide karta hai, aur is test me sirf APA check kiya gaya tha. Reference me volume, issue aur pages hain, "385(6), 493–502", saath me DOI bhi.

Elicit ne kya kiya

Humne Elicit ko draft se trial sentence diya. Usne kaha ki sentence trial se match karta hai aur trial paper ka naam bataya, jo Gillmore et al. ka tha. Iske 10 results ki table me trial 3rd number par tha, ek 2022 review aur ek company press release ke baad.

Elicit results table ka screenshot: 2022 ka review, ek press release, phir 2021 ka NEJM trial teesre number par highlighted

Elicit table ka top hissa, jisme 2021 trial third place par hai

Har paper ek panel me title, authors, journal, DOI aur abstract ke saath khulta hai. Koi formatted reference nahi hai aur add karne ke liye koi citation nahi hai, kyunki Elicit me aapke draft ke liye koi editor nahi hai.

📰 Trial ko cite karein, uske review ko nahi: Elicit table ki pehli row ek 2022 review thi jo trial ko second hand report karti hai. Khud 2021 trial paper ko hi cite karein

Clunky sentence ko fix karna: ek marked rewrite ya ek plain rewrite

Winner - Jenni, kyunki iska rewrite har change ko dikhata hai, is note ke saath ki kya badlaav hua hai. Dono tools ne 2 grammar mistakes ko fix kar diya.

Jenni - iska fluency edit, jo aapke select kiye gaye sentence ki wording ko smooth banata hai, 43 words ko kam karke 28 kar diya. Isne ye return kiya:

"Several questions remain, including how the particles behave outside the liver, whether repeat dosing triggers an immune response, and what the long-term editing outcomes are at off-target sites."

Jenni rewrite ka screenshot, jisme hataye gaye shabd laal mein kate hain, 'Several questions remain' jaise naye shabd hare mein hain

Jenni rewrite har change ko mark karta hai, uske neeche ek note ke saath

Hataye gaye words red me crossed out dikhte hain aur naye green me, taaki aap naye sentence ke replace hone se pehle har badlaav ko check kar sakein.

Elicit - iska rewrite akela aaya, 27 words bina kisi note ke: "Many questions remain, including how the particles behave outside the liver, whether repeat dosing triggers an immune response, and what long-term editing outcomes occur at off-target sites." Isko use karne ke liye, apne sentence se compare karein aur ise paste karein.

📝 Plain rewrite ko word-by-word padhein: Bina list of changes wala rewrite kisi important word ko drop kar sakta hai. Kisi bhi cheez ko replace karne se pehle apne sentence ke saath ise check karein

File export karna: ek LaTeX thesis file ya markdown download

Winner - Jenni, pehle se set thesis layout ke saath chapter ki .tex file ke liye. Elicit chat answer markdown, ek plain-text format me download hota hai.

Jenni se export karna

Jenni aapke draft ko Word ya LaTeX me export karta hai, jo ek typesetting format hai. Agar aap apni thesis LaTeX me likhte hain, toh "Thesis or report" naam ka layout chunein: "Report class, 12pt, 1.5 spacing, with a table of contents."

Jenni ke LaTeX export layouts ka screenshot, jisme 'Thesis or report' bhi hai: report class, 12pt, 1.5 spacing, table of contents

Jenni thesis layout ke saath ready LaTeX export karta hai

Elicit se export karna

Elicit answer me 2 buttons hote hain, Copy response aur Download as markdown. Elicit ka help page kehta hai ki iski Research Reports PDF ya Word files ke roop me export hoti hain, aur humne export test nahi kiya.

🧾 Export ko apni thesis template se match karein: Submit karne se pehle margins, spacing aur font ko apni university ya department ki di hui template se zaroor check karein

Apne chapter ko LaTeX thesis file ke roop me save karein

Draft ko Thesis or report layout ke saath .tex file me export karein, 12pt with 1.5 spacing aur table of contents ke saath

Free me Likhna Shuru Karein

Kai papers se details nikaalna: ek aisa kaam jo Jenni nahi karta

Winner - Elicit, kyunki isne human trials ki 9-row table ki har row ke liye same 2 columns fill kiye. Jenni ke paas aisi koi table nahi hai.

Test paragraph ek trial par based hai, isliye humne Elicit se poocha ki humans me kin clinical trials ne is tarah ke treatment ko test kiya hai. Isne 9 results ki ek table di, jisme 2021 trial sabse pehle tha.

Phir humne 2 columns add kiye, har ek me ek line ka instruction tha: treated logon ki sankhya, aur time point ke saath main result. Elicit ne sabhi 9 rows ke liye dono columns fill kiye. Screenshot me, 2 naye columns ke har cell me us paper ka naam hai jahan se uska answer aaya hai.

Elicit table ka screenshot jisme columns jode gaye hain: 2021 trial mein 6 participants hain aur day 28 par TTR 52% aur 87% ghata

Elicit ne har paper ke liye participants aur main result fill kiya

2021 trial ke liye isne 6 participants aur "At day 28, mean serum TTR fell 52% at 0.1 mg/kg and 87% at 0.3 mg/kg." diya.

TTR test ka blood protein hai, aur mg/kg body weight ke prati kilogram dose hai. Ye wahi details hain jo test draft me chhut gayi thi: kitne logon ka treat kiya gaya, aur 87% ke peeche exact dose kya thi.

Isne apne khud ke gaps ko bhi flag kiya. Ek paper ke abstract me ye nahi bataya gaya tha ki result kab measure hua, aur ek row company announcement ki thi jisme koi results nahi the.

🗂️ Har table cell ko uske paper se check karein: Jis bhi number ko aap cite karne ka plan bana rahe hain, uske peeche ka source open karein. Aisi table studies ka ek map hoti hai, aur paper saboot hota hai

Jenni kahan aage hai

  • Draft ke andar fixes - Claim confidence edit accept karein aur sentence badal jaata hai, jisme suggestion me uska source quote hota hai.

  • Ek click me complete reference - citation aur uski APA entry, volume, issue aur pages ke saath.

  • Rewrites jinhe aap check kar sakte hain - har badlaav marked hota hai, is note ke saath ki kya change hua hai.

  • Thesis shape me LaTeX file - export me table of contents ke saath thesis layout ek option hai.

Elicit ke paas kya hai jo Jenni ke paas nahi hai

  • Aisi tables jo kai papers se details nikaalti hain - ek column add karein, aur Elicit ise har paper ke liye fill kar deta hai. Jenni ka sabse close feature AI Chat hai, jo aapke Jenni me save kiye gaye papers ke baare me citations ke saath sawalon ke jawab deta hai.

  • Systematic reviews ke liye screening workflow - Elicit ke pricing page par ek workflow listed hai jo 5,000 papers screen kar sakta hai. Jenni ke paas koi screening tool nahi hai. Iska sabse closest option aapke PDFs aur Zotero ya Mendeley imports ke liye ek library hai.

  • List ke har paper par ek summary - Elicit table ki har row me ek summary hoti hai. Jenni ke search cards iski jagah citation counts, impact factor aur paper ka ek passage dikhaate hain.

Dono tools ki cost kya hai

Plan

Jenni

Elicit

Free plan

Free - $0; rozana 10 AI Autocompletes (sentence completions); 3 AI Edits (rewrites); 5 AI Chat messages; 3 Reviews (draft checks); unlimited citations

Basic - $0; 138 million se zyada papers me unlimited search; Research Agent (chat jo humne in tests ke liye use kiya) aur Research Reports ka limited use

Pehla paid plan

Plus - $30 prati maheena, ya $144 prati saal

Plus - $19 prati maheena, ya $132 prati saal

Doosra paid plan

Pro - $73 prati maheena, ya $348 prati saal

Pro - $69 prati maheena, ya $468 prati saal

Teesra paid plan

Koi teesra paid plan nahi

Scale - $149 prati maheena, ya $1,068 prati saal

Prices jenni.ai/pricing aur elicit.com/pricing se hain.

  • Yearly billing - ek saath ek saal ke liye pay karna kaafi sasta padta hai. Jenni Plus $144 prati saal hai, jabki 12 monthly payments ke liye $360 padta hai.

  • Pehla paid plan - Elicit Plus ki cost $19 hai ($30 ke mukable), aur yearly me $132 hai ($144 ke mukable).

  • Doosra paid plan - yearly billing par, Jenni Pro ki cost $348 aati hai ($468 ke mukable). Monthly billing par iski cost $73 aati hai ($69 ke mukable).

  • Jenni Plus me kya shamil hai - 500 AI Edits aur 10 Reviews prati maheena. Jenni Pro dono limits hata deta hai.

  • Elicit Plus me kya add hota hai - reference-manager files (RIS, BIB), spreadsheets (CSV), PDF aur Word (DOCX) me export, aur ek baar me 5 table columns tak.

  • Elicit prices ke baare me - ye iske Academic plans hain. Pricing page Industry plans par open hota hai, jahan Pro aur Scale yearly billing par zyada costly hain, isliye Academic par switch karein.

Aapko kaun sa use karna chahiye?

Agar aapka supervisor poochta hai ki koi figure kahan se aaya

Jenni use karein - paragraph par Claim confidence chalayein, un edits ko accept karein jo aapke source se match karte hain, aur agar source support karta hai toh edit dwara hatayi gayi kisi bhi detail ko restore karein. Phir Jenni ke citation search se source ko cite karein, jo usi draft me iska poora reference add kar deta hai.

Apne draft ko chhode bina source cite karein

Jenni aapke cursor wale sentence ke liye papers search karta hai, phir ek click me citation aur uska poora APA reference add karta hai

Free me Likhna Shuru Karein

Agar aap likhne se pehle kai studies review kar rahe hain

Dono use karein - Elicit me studies ki table banayein, jisme aapko chahiye har detail ke liye ek column ho. Papers ko BibTeX ya RIS file ke roop me export karein (dekhein What each tool costs) aur ise Jenni me import karein. Phir wahan chapter likhein aur har us paper ko cite karein jise aap rakhna chahte hain.

Agar aapka chapter LaTeX ke roop me jaata hai

Jenni use karein - thesis layout ke saath export karein. References iske saath .bib file ke roop me chale jaate hain.

Elicit me studies ko map karein. Chapter ko Jenni me likhein jo unhe cite karta hai, jahan har claim check hota hai aur har citation list me apna reference add karta hai.

Aaj aap apne sabse mahan karya par pragati karein

Aaj hi Jenni ke saath apna pehla paper likho aur kabhi peeche na dekho

Muft mein shuru karein

Kisi credit card ki zaroorat nahi hai

Kabhi bhi cancel karein

Shuru likhna- yeh muft hai

5 million se adhik

Vishwa-vyapi academics

5.2 ghante bachaye

Aam taur par prat ek kagaz par

15 se zyada

Jenni par likhe gaye papers